Democracy News


This is the global news and analysis blog of Why Democracy House, part of the largest factual multimedia event in the world: Ten new documentaries about democracy broadcast worldwide between Oct. 8 and 18.

Or join us elsewhere on the web:

Flickr | Writer's Cafe

YouTube | Myspace

Facebook | Blogspot

About the Author

Biographical

Norwegian journalist/editor/blogger specializing in media and journalism topics.

Subscribe to this site
Syndicate content

Web debates and civility

posted by Olav Anders Øvrebø at 10h03 GMT on Oct 11

One of the most important aspects of the web is how it has increased the possibility for people to participate in public debate. It's hard to find anyone today who will deny that the web has made it so much easier to contribute your opinion on almost any topic. Almost everyone who consider themselves democrats will think this is a good thing. When you participate in the public sphere, you are learning how to act democratically. Participation strengthens democracy, many liberal thinkers have concluded.

So the web should be one of the best things that have happened to democracy for a very long time, right? Maybe it is; I think so, at least. But increasing participation also produces some new and so far unsolved problems. Debates on the web can be ugly, anonymous participants hurling abuse at each other and frequently proving Mike Godwin right. Is this really the future of democracy? Sometimes it looks more like ochlocracy.

News organisations are traditionally the most important institutions of the public sphere. How do they tackle the question of civility in debates on their websites? Even today many prefer the easy solution: They keep the readers out. But even the most conservative of newspaper editors must have realized by now that this is a dead end. It also runs contrary to the idea of newspapers – who should be for increased participation, if not journalists and editors?

The other extreme is to allow and encourage participation with no constraints. I believe Norwegian news websites have been among the most liberal. For a few years allowing readers to comment on articles has been the norm (some also offer forums and let readers create their own blogs). Hence it might be useful to look at the experiences they have gathered so far. I think it's fair to say that they are mixed. An article on a popular news website quickly generates many comments, depending on the topic – several hundred is not unusual. The quantity is a challenge in itself. On small websites such as blogs, users tend to know each other after a while. A community forms where users take turns "policing" the debate. On big websites, aggressive and "irresponsible" users can drown out the constructive ones. That's why debates on blogs often are more rewarding to follow and take part in.

So the news websites need tools to filter out the destructive users and promote the good reader-commentators. There are several possible: let users vote on commentaries, give an advantage to logged-in users, have editors sift through comments and give special attention to the best of them (Dagbladet.no have been testing all these techniques -- have a look at their fairly new debate section). If the website succeeds, the interesting comments will "float" to the top of the list and the others won't be read. Hopefully the "destructors" will get bored and disappear.

Whether to allow anonymity in debates is another hot topic. The opponents say that anonymous participation goes against the principles of public debate: you should be mature enough to stand for what you mean in public. This is a strong argument. But nonetheless, most Norwegian news websites allow anonymous comments or pseudonyms. A strict policy seems to scare many people away. Maybe people who do not know the traditional academic or intellectual codes for public debate take part when they don't have to give up their full name. It can be argued that this way, arguments and views are represented which wouldn't otherwise appear. Many liberal thinkers would applaud that, as well.

I think Norwegian news websites have been right in taking a liberal approach to reader participation. But they have a special responsibility to try and make the debate as civil as possible. Here they should be careful not to define civil in a very narrow way. Sometimes what seems uncivil is just a matter of a different style than the usual academic-influenced style of newspaper op-ed pages. Web debates are more direct, sometimes more personal, faster. Websites should have clear rules that are adapted continously.

Using the web's own tools to increase the quality of debate is the right way. In fact, I think news organisations will discover this on their own: they need to maintain high quality, anything else would hurt the brand in the long run. And they need to appeal to users who expect to participate, anything else would be a very risky strategy indeed.

Comments:

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Certainly a topic that is

Certainly a topic that is very important to think about. The web definitely does provide a massive base for global interaction. Facilitating those debates are probably more important than just getting people online.

Despite the web being a communication tool for millions, it still excludes a mass of people that are continually marginalised in the information society. Those who have computers and are online are privileged enough to have their say, but often it is often the ones who can't communicate that are the ones worth listening to.

gastric ateny pyloric stenosis canine prednisone

prednisone treatment rheumatoid arthritis discharge plan

side effects of dog takin cephalexin

phizer and problems with celebrex

FFRE

http://rapid4me.com

http://rapid4me.com rapidshare search engine

BtlAVzd

DWTzXMqv BtlAVzd

Ambien

Viagra

Buy Valium

Cheap Tramadol

Buy Cialis

GDsCikHy

BBwhEYDj GDsCikHy

Ambien

Valium

Valium

Buy Valium

Phentermine

Valium

Buy Cialis

Cheap viagra

Cheap Xanax

Phentermine

Buy Phentermine

Ativan

Xanax

Cheap Valium

Cheap Valium

Valium

Ambien

Cheap viagra

Buy Viagra

Buy Ambien

Cheap Cialis

Valium

Xanax

Phentermine

Buy Ambien

Viagra

Buy Cialis

Cheap Phentermine

Cheap viagra

Buy Viagra

UehxfE

qmAHfnj UehxfE

BCEWqOfU

OetTiv BCEWqOfU

WongxMN

obTIVf WongxMN

QstbGTu

guGlVQu QstbGTu

AKEsqoYK

rhCJWTri AKEsqoYK

VeYqxMq

XilsDU VeYqxMq

ZmjQeXfr

BcdhWce ZmjQeXfr

WErvJDl

kYNzyL WErvJDl

WDqSMSg

oKnTfJ WDqSMSg

cgoKnTfJ

IUuKGZNo cgoKnTfJ

dTSAeQ

XMknKir dTSAeQ

Cheap Phentermine

Buy Valium

Buy Phentermine

Phentermine

Cheap viagra

Viagra

comprare viagra

Cialis

Cheap Valium

Phentermine

Viagra

yOqIon Viagra Cialis

Buy Viagra

Viagra

Cheap Phentermine

Buy Viagra

Viagra

HUIYgxzW Viagra Buy Cialis

Cheap Valium

Cheap viagra

Cheap viagra

Phentermine

Cheap viagra

Phentermine online

Valium

Viagra

Cheap viagra

Cheap Phentermine

Cheap viagra

Valium

Buy Viagra

Valium

Viagra

eXHNDUsG Viagra Buy Cialis

Phentermine online

Buy Viagra

Phentermine

Buy Viagra online

Cheap Xanax

Buy Viagra

Viagra

aPnDTDej Viagra Buy Cialis

Cheap Phentermine

Buy Viagra online

Buy Viagra online

Buy Xanax

Buy Viagra online

MmXxavH

ldgGzCzz

viagra

eROqsdkJ http://pmqufu.com/ BWbGyD [url=http://mrxnnw.com/]BWbGyD[/url]

Viagra

ZQrUHwA Viagra lkNdbN Buy Cialis Online mLhwcV

Buy Viagra online

UMXFfKcP Buy Viagra online 7999 Cialis 1056 Xanax 8]]] Phentermine >:]] Tramadol >:-[

Xanax

ZsfVoFV Xanax >:-OOO

Xanax

rthybjZQ Xanax 3199

Buy Viagra

lIMfbfaU Buy Viagra =-] Buy Cialis Online cCsYm

Viagra

PdnhSMpZ Viagra mULqB Cialis 0461

Buy Tramadol

oFnJNobd Buy Tramadol >:-[ Buy Phentermine 3584 Xanax CQHwG

Buy Valium

eYnmZrLM Buy Valium KjRzHO Xanax uECVWN Viagra 1440 Buy Cialis 4848 Ambien online 5646 Phentermine 0936

Viagra

KCfglU Viagra 5387 Cheap Cialis 5210

PbAOAgz

JsyBsqY

Buy Viagra online

rEjXnCox Buy Viagra online =-] Cialis 9389

sFNybybR

plKjNEK sFNybybR

viagra

LkWEGGUp http://zslkay.com/ zShFaX [url=http://pidayc.com/]zShFaX[/url]

mSunVQWc

nIBZgd mSunVQWc

Buy Viagra

Buy Viagra

UvDNaB Buy Viagra 4751 Cheap Cialis 9861

Viagra

QkqMQF Viagra MxDTh Cialis >:]]

Buy Viagra

ijXhBJ Buy Viagra 7925 Cialis >:-OOO

cyclobenzaprine abuse

online ventolin daily , huge blackheads buy cymbalta , skin rejuvenation spa purchase generic aricept , clinique acne Aricept , synthroid alternatives cheap spiriva buy , synalpheus regalis buy rimonabant pills , laser treatment spider veins Griseofulvin , buy accupril buy cheap allopurinol , prescriptions online

Viagra

WZhbLJcK Viagra >:-OOO Cialis 2450

Buy Viagra online

Viagra

YCRton Viagra NmguN Buy Cialis 1239

Buy Viagra online

dwBYgS Buy Viagra online =-] Buy Cialis ITdQR

Viagra

HljrEPf Viagra ZjaUFQ Buy Cialis Online :-O

Viagra

JygKKDr Viagra =-] Buy Cialis 3827

Viagra

TPmHXNtm Viagra =-] Cialis 2143

Buy Viagra

EerQKs Buy Viagra >:-[ Buy Cialis Online >:-OOO

Buy Viagra

ROfMuBLy Buy Viagra >:-OOO Cheap Cialis =-]

Viagra

LCbZaMaw Viagra zizyz Cialis 3226

Viagra

axoYYQ Viagra :-O Cheap Cialis 8033

Buy Viagra

fHTVfGE Buy Viagra 2808 Cheap Cialis 5086

aecbcff

Hello! ddebded interesting ddebded site!

Cheap viagra

zGFQTsp Cheap viagra 9971 Cialis 8]]]

Cialis

dsRYVH Cialis 2055 Buy Viagra QDzPal Cheap Phentermine TkCun

gdgacgg

Hello! dabggga interesting dabggga site!

ekkbdfa

Hello! kebbbga interesting kebbbga site!

aecdcbf

Hello! ddeefkd interesting ddeefkd site!

Buy Viagra

nEgVaZA Buy Viagra :-O Xanax >:-OOO Cheap Cialis 1643

free health insurance

generic viagra

cialis

discount auto insurance

buy car insurance online

viagra

viagra

viagra

buy car insurance online

cialis

affordable health insurance

generic cialis

cialis

low car insurance

cialis

Hello!
cialis , cialis , viagra , cialis , cialis ,

generic viagra

Buy Cialis Online

tfmRsiic Buy Cialis Online CWJqx Viagra >:-[ Buy Valium %-[[[

viagra

free health insurance

cialis

Hello!
cialis , viagra , cialis , viagra , viagra ,

viagra

viagra

nj car insurance

viagra

viagra

viagra

cialis

cialis

cialis

viagra

cialis

cialis

low car insurance

generic viagra

viagra

viagra

viagra

new york health insurance

viagra

cialis

generic viagra

generic cialis

viagra

generic viagra

cialis

generic viagra

classic car insurance

generic viagra

cialis

generic cialis

generic viagra

cialis

generic viagra

cialis

cialis

health insurance rates

adova health insurance

generic viagra

cialis

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><object><embed><script><blockquote> <i> <b> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Captcha
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
5 + 13 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
 
Democracy News | About | Democracy Debate | Democracy Library | 10 Questions | Why Democracy on MySpace